Apr 20, 2016

The Subtle Misdirection of Spider-Woman's Baby Daddy

There will be spoilers for the new Spider-Woman series. 

When Marvel relaunched their line last year, they jumped forward into continuity by eight months. The relaunched Spider-Woman, written by Dennis Hopeless and illustrated by Javier Rodriguez (note: my #1 reason for buying the book) had a simple hook for the new direction: she was pregnant.



Instantly, I as a reader who had been following Spider-Woman since the last series asked, "So who's the dad?" After all, in the entire previous series, Spider-Woman didn't have a love interest. And if it weren't going to be a big reveal, why would they hide the identity of the dad? They even make a point of hiding it early on at the expense of a certain Armored Avenger.


The story takes Jessica Drew into an intergalactic hospital, where she's sitting with a bunch of alien soon-to-be moms. And I, for one, considered the possibility that the dad was an alien character we've met before.



And yet, when Spider-Woman gives birth in the story, the baby is perfectly human.



And at the end of the story, Jessica finally comes clean to Carol Danvers (Captain Marvel). There is no dad.



She was dating someone and was disappointed at a negative pregnancy test. So she got a donor.



Motherhood wasn't something that happened to Jessica Drew. She chose it.



And Dennis Hopeless and Javier Rodriguez made us dwell on the identity of the dad, thinking the dad was the point of the story. But they did the most mundane payoff possible, and I wouldn't have it any other way. The story was never about who the father was. The story was always about Jessica Drew, a woman who chose to have a child. And if we paid attention to the story, that was always the point. But we focused too much on what wasn't there — the dad — to see it.

15 comments:

cecilx said...

that was a nice ending but it was bait eather anyone wants to admit it or not hahaha

Duy Tano said...

Serialized fiction uses cliffhangers and unanswered questions to keep you coming back? You don't say.

Anonymous said...

Poor kid. Mommy can't do anything today, gotta go fight crime. Worse than those celebrities with their trophy kids or teenagers who want a baby for whatever stupid reason. Strikes me as irresponsible and setting a bad example.

Duy Tano said...

Or, maybe, any parent with a job?

Unknown said...

What will be her child's name?

Duy Tano said...

It's Gerry.

Rickie Woodson said...

doner or no doner the baby still has a dad so....TELL US WHO HE IS

OpNa said...

Felt like a feminist trap.. "we don't need men and we can still be super women." makes sense since marvels going all.. sjw on us.

OpNa said...

Felt like a feminist trap.. "we don't need men and we can still be super women." makes sense since marvels going all.. sjw on us.

Duy Tano said...

Yes, because Marvel has never been about diversity and treating people equally.

Juan Rojo said...

Wait. If the father is a donor and she has no idea who he is, then why she felt offended when Tony asked her if she knew who was the father? She evidently no, so...
Oh. I see. She just assumed he was suggesting that she was going out a lot. Typical. How many "malpensados" there are.

Annette Adkins said...

Seriously one of my favorite blog

Dan Carter said...

The father is Peter Parker.

Dan Carter said...

I am going to say that the father of Jessica's child is Peter Parker. Jessica does not simply accept a random donor. If Peter made a donation to the sperm bank, then Jessica would know. If there was one person who Jessica wants to father her child, it would be Peter Parker. Hopeless already made a few hints who the father is.

Godric said...

@Dan Carter

That’s what I was thinking, he wouldn’t NEED to know, and with his various financial troubles prior to, and after Horizon and Parker industries, I’m sure at some point “off panel” one of his friends might have suggested it. Maybe Harry, maybe Johnny in jest, but if it paid just enough for that next batch of web fluid when he was hard up, I CAN see him doing it.

That said, he’s so “responsible” the moment he found out “Gerald” is his, he’s be trying to contribute... and rather self depreciatingly to “support” the kid.

Remember, Pete’s a orphan raised by a “single mom” after uncle Ben died. So... yeah, much to the chagrin of MJ or any other life partner Pete might have, he’d try to jump right in.

Post a Comment

All comments on The Comics Cube need approval (mostly because of spam) and no anonymous comments are allowed. Please leave your name if you wish to leave a comment. Thanks!