Death and Resurrection: Why Most Comic Book Fans Are Wrong
There seems to be this weird complaint among a subsection of comic book fandom that changes in superhero comics are never permanent. This is especially true when it comes to death. Whether the death of a character is permanent or not, I believe the most important thing is if it is an entertaining story or not.
I can somewhat understand the viewpoint of superhero deaths that are done as a “stunt,” but even then I don’t really agree with it. “They’re just trying to get us to buy this comic.” Well yeah, isn’t that kind of the whole point? If anything, I’ll grant them the assumption that some comic book deaths are thrown into the story to give it an extra sense of importance, and aren’t narratively driven at all (most likely to occur in the less enjoyable of event crossovers, cough cough Fear Itself).
Even Fear Itself, as cheap as Bucky Cap’s “death” initially seemed to be, ended up serving a bigger purpose by forcing Steve back into the spotlight, and returning Bucky to the much better role of Winter Soldier. Most of the more significant superhero deaths that have occurred over the past decade I feel like were story-driven deaths that marketing took advantage of, and not some devious plot by the publishers to force you to buy comics against your will.
Exploring what a character’s death means to their world, is one of the distinct advantages of the genre. No other entertainment medium is really able to take advantage of that type of story the way that comic books can, and do. For that reason, I’m going to share some of my favorite deaths in comics.
Of course, SPOILERS from this point on. You’ve been adequately warned.
First up, is a death that I covered recently when talking about my love of the character of Damian Wayne. Damian went out in the most comic book of ways, fighting his own hyper-aged clone.
The subsequent grief of the bat-family, especially Batman himself, is what really sells this one for me. That’s what sells a great death story for me, if it can tap into the indescribable grief that comes from losing a loved one.
Next up, is the lovely Karen Page, struck down by the irredeemable Bullseye.
As she dies in Daredevil’s arms, she chokes out a few last words (a common trope) which never fails to connect with me when done right. (I think my last words in a scenario like that would be “You are terrible at this, Daredevil.")
The death of Peter Parker in the Ultimate universe has perhaps the most fitting and touching final words of anything else on this list.
Following that, the death of Peter Parker in the regular Marvel universe, after getting mind-swapped into the body of Doctor Octopus, totally worked for me on a different level. His final pleas with Otto to do the right thing elevate it far above the “stunt” comic that many irrational online fans proclaim it to be.
Driving the knife in even further, Peter is seemingly erased for good from his own brain only a few months after. A truly heartbreaking scene.
No list would be complete without including the suicide of Jean Grey as the Phoenix, one of the most popular and beloved stories in Marvel history.
Probably the most painful death for me as a reader (that didn’t involve me being an adolescent) was the death of U-Go Girl in X-Force.
Equally sudden, shocking, and unexpected, it just kills me every single time.
My favorite example of the kinds of emotional stories that can be told from the death of a beloved character comes as part of the final stand of Johnny Storm, the Human Torch.
Without his “death,” we don’t get these heart-rending scenes with Susan Richards…
or this chilling scene between Reed Richards and Annihilus.
or the anger of Valeria…
These were (forgive the pun) fantastic scenes, and they aren’t possible without Johnny’s seeming death.
Nothing hits me harder than the selfless sacrifice play, and there aren’t many better than the climatic battle between Star-Lord, Nova, and Thanos.
My next entry should come as no surprise to any longtime readers, the Barry Allen Flash.
Not to be outdone, the death of the Green Goblin in the following issue was just as compelling.
“Crucified, not on a cross of gold--but on a stake of humble tin.”
This last death is a favorite simply because it makes me smile every time I see it.
It never gets old.
Deaths have provided some of the most emotional moments and storytelling that comic books can offer. It’s a great way to explore, or remind readers, what makes a character special. When done right, the reactions of the character’s family and friends are what really drive the emotion home. Bypassing that because of some cynical view of their lack of permanence seems like a bit of a waste.
U-Go Girl and Gwen Stacy probably aren’t coming back, and that stings. But the depressing solitude of Peter as he slowly gets erased is just as painful, and that will never change, even after he comes back. The overwhelming grief of the Fantastic Four isn’t any less beautifully done because Johnny Storm was eventually revived. The unfortunate return of Superman doesn’t make his sacrifice any less heroic.
Death is just one tool in the superhero comic book storytelling arsenal. If you can’t buy into the moment because of your own expectations for what happens next, then that is too bad. It’s not the writer’s fault, or marketing’s, or the company’s. It’s your fault. Don’t blame it on comics.
You can get some of these stories here: